Archive for August, 2015

Singapore Musical Theatre

11 August 2015

Singapore Musical Theatre
by Kenneth Lyen
In Singapore Soundscape edited by Jun Zubillaga-Pow and Ho Chee Kong

Believe

Ever since Singapore became independent, the government has been trying to forge a unique Singapore identity. Two decades of exceptional economic growth lifted Singapore from a Third World into a First World country, and the basic necessities of employment, housing, health and education were largely met. Singaporeans had more time for leisure and were now clamouring for the higher things in life. Art and entertainment were no longer trivial subsidiary components; they had become essential elements of the good life. Musical theatre quickly assumed that role. It told stories that the public could identify with, embellished with a youthful and earnest corp of singers, actors and dancers.

In the 1970s, Singapore was regarded as a ‘cultural desert’. Committees on music, literature, drama, art and dance were established by the government in 1977 to accelerate cultural development. In 1989, the government published the Report of the Advisory Council on Culture and the Arts. The then Deputy Prime Minister Ong Teng Cheong wrote, ‘Countries all over the world are recognising the positive impact of the arts on the economy.’ In order to attract overseas talent to live and work in Singapore, the country needed to transform itself into a gracious society and become an artistically vibrant city. The arts would play a major role in this endeavour. While the motivation for promoting the arts was initially economic, nevertheless the government did commit to the establishment of the National Arts Council and the investment of $600 million in the development of the Esplanade, a complex of theatres, a concert hall and a performing arts library. Furthermore, it liberalised its attitudes towards censorship.

Prior to 1988, the only musicals seen in Singapore were Western imports from Broadway and the West End. Their influence was pervasive but the companies that performed these shows did little in terms of technology transfer. There was no tradition of Singapore librettist, lyricists, composers, producers, directors, choreographers, designers and engineers. There were no experienced mentors to guide the novice creative and performing teams. The Singapore musical had to start from scratch.

Because Singapore sits at a crossroads between the East and the West, its theatre and musical influences are mainly from Britain and the United States on the one hand and, to a smaller extent, from China and Japan on the other. To an even lesser extent, there are also influences derived from Southeast Asia and India. Interestingly, English-language musicals have continued to dominate the landscape. It could be argued that after nearly 140 years of British rule, when the only musicals performed in Singapore were Gilbert and Sullivan, Noel Coward and other West End musicals, one should not be surprised that Singapore would begin by imitating British musicals.

As the urge to create became overwhelming, two theatre companies created the first Singapore musicals in 1988. Act 3 assembled a team and produced Makanplace, while TheatreWorks originated Beauty World. Despite the lack of experience and no track record, both theatre companies created stories and characters that Singaporeans could identify with, accompanied by appealing and danceable songs. These pioneer Singapore musicals were exuberant and competent and were instant successes, performing to sell-out crowds.

Subsequently, many more locally-written musicals were created, but the attendance at these productions has been inconsistent at best. Most Singapore musicals were unable to sustain a run longer than a couple of weeks. By contrast, imported shows from the United States and Britain, like Phantom of the Opera, Chicago and Les Misérables, not only had relatively longer runs but were also brought back for multiple runs.

What are the reasons for the short runs of Singapore musicals? In the main, support for locally-written musicals is not as strong compared to foreign imports. A large percentage of the population speaks Chinese as a first language. The segment that speaks English well and attends English-language theatre remains relatively small. In addition, musicals with a short run often do not break even. Without adequate profits, production companies have to rely heavily on corporate sponsorships and government subsidies. Unfortunately, government help is accompanied by restrictions in terms of what is deemed acceptable for public performance. For example, funding support has been reduced when a production company produces shows that glorify alternative lifestyles or are too risqué. Because of the fragile nature of obtaining regular funding, and the uncertainty of commercial success, production companies are reluctant to take risks and often cut costs to minimise potential losses. As a result, production values suffer.

Otherwise, a few successful Singapore musicals like Beauty World (1988) and Chang and Eng (1997) have travelled overseas in Asia. While Beauty World toured the Japanese cities of Fukuoka, Hiroshima, Osaka and Tokyo, Chang and Eng was performed in Bangkok, Beijing and Hong Kong. To date, however, no Singapore musical has made it to Broadway or the West End. Neither have Singapore musicals achieved international quality. Why is this?

Foremost, Singapore is a relatively young, independent nation and its musical theatre is even younger. Entering so late onto the international scene can be a disadvantage. On the one hand, writers and composers write for their audience. In general, the average Singapore audience prefers low-brow humour and melodic songs, and tends to avoid intellectual or deeply emotional themes. Knowing this, the creative teams write accordingly. Thus, two decades have not been long enough for Singapore writers and composers to discover their own voice.

On the other hand, Singapore writers and composers are not bound by West End or Broadway traditions. One might have expected them to look at the musical from a fresh perspective and to be more experimental in their efforts. However, they tend to be rather conservative. There may be many Asian stories to tell, and indeed the Singapore musical does well in telling these stories, but the stories chosen tend to be rather bland and without intellectual or emotional depth.

International versus Local

Art and entertainment in the globalised world of today is heavily influenced by the West. When the inexperienced writer or composer faces an audience brought up on a diet of Western musicals, it is doubly difficult to find that unique Singaporean voice. This includes telling stories, creating characters, describing the physical and emotional landscape, and expressing the values, history and personal experiences of Singapore and its peoples. Furthermore, most homegrown musicals generally do not have a sufficiently rigorous developmental process of polishing and refining, so the final product fails to achieve an international calibre.

Singapore audiences like to identify with their characters and, if the story is set locally, it is then expected that they will speak Singlish, a colloquial form of English. It incorporates words from Malay, Hokkien and other Southeast Asian languages. Singlish often raises laughs among Singaporeans, and its use in theatre is mildly subversive: the Singapore government frowns on and actively discourages Singlish in schools and public broadcasting. Also, non-Singaporeans may have difficulty understanding Singlish, and too much of it might reduce a show’s exportability.

Therefore the writer is caught in a dilemma – should one write for an international audience with the hope that these shows can travel overseas? Or should one write something that reflects the authentic local culture? Theatre companies, aware of the relatively small size of the Singapore theatre-going audience, try to produce shows for an international audience, hoping to export these shows overseas. The need to write for an international audience inevitably influences their style of writing. Because of this dilemma, English-language musical theatre will continue to face difficulties finding its own voice in Singapore because of the nation’s varied uses of English.

There is also a shortage of good scriptwriters in Singapore. The scriptwriter is responsible for the story as well as the spoken dialogue. It is important for the success of a musical that the writer tells a compelling story and develops interesting characters. As a result, some songwriters, like Dick Lee, have frequently collaborated with non-Singaporeans in their musicals. Dick Lee teamed up with British and American writers Steven Dexter and Tony Petito and lyricist Anthony Drewe for the musical A Twist of Fate, and British writer Stephen Clark for the musicals Sing to the Dawn and Forbidden City. Some have argued that to develop a truly Singapore musical, there needs to be less reliance on non-Singaporean writers.

The music component of Singapore musicals seems to have become stuck in the period between 1950 and 1970. Beauty World has a Latino slant, Nagraland leans towards Indonesian ethnic music and Chang and Eng features a lyrical Broadway style with Asian elements. The music of many English-language musicals sounds like church music: not gospel music, but rather contemporary Christian music. The music is melodic and the harmony tries to be slightly unpredictable so as to give it a modern feel. The structure follows the traditional verse-chorus plus bridge convention.

Chinese-language musicals, on the other hand, are influenced by the xinyao style, a genre of songs unique to Singapore. Xinyao songs have a unique style with a clear melodic line, sung by one or more singers usually accompanied by a guitar. Liang Wern Fook is a proponent of this xinyao style, and his two musicals, December Rains (1996/2010) and If There’re Seasons (2009) are of this genre. However, not all Chinese-language musicals employ the xinyao style. For example, Liao Zhai Rocks! (2010) employs mostly rock music. What is conspicuously missing among Singapore musicals is a lyric-centred style of songwriting exemplified by the works of Stephen Sondheim and Jason Robert Brown.

Chinese-Language Musicals

In its early years, all Singapore musicals were written in English; it is only from the mid-1990s that Chinese-language musicals gradually made their appearance. Despite being performed in Chinese, the structure and style of Chinese-language musicals reflect Broadway and West End musicals. One of these musicals is Mr. Beng (1999/2000), which was produced by Drama Box and staged at the World Trade Centre Auditorium. The librettist was Otto Fong and the music composed by Iskandar Ismail; the musical was directed by Kok Heng Leun. The story follows the rise and fall of Chow Kok Beng, a young contractor who strives to discard his image of being ‘beng’ (a man perceived to be loutish and uncouth) after falling in love with Peach, a wealthy English-educated brat. He falls prey to Peach’s coaxing to alter his lifestyle and to discard his ‘beng’ friends for the finer things of life, such as dining in French restaurants and speaking proper English. However, he is unaware that Peach is only putting on an act of loving him so as to crush him both financially and emotionally. The dialogue and lyrics are in English, Mandarin and Hokkien, and could be confusing for those who do not understand all three.

Another Chinese-language musical is Lao Jiu (2005), which was produced by The Theatre Practice and staged at the Drama Centre. Based on a 1990 play by Kuo Pao Kun, it was adapted into a musical by librettists Zhang Xian and Wu Xi, with dialogue in Mandarin and Hokkien. The lyrics were written by Yang Qian, Wu Xi and Xiao Han, with music composed by Jonathan Price and puppetry by Tan Beng Tian and Rene Ong. The show was directed by Kuo Jian Hong and choreographed by Kuo Jing Hong. The title refers to the ninth and last child, the only son, born to the Chng family. They have a family friend, a traditional Chinese puppeteer, who predicts before birth that the boy will be talented and intelligent. Indeed, the predictions come true and the boy excels in his studies. He is invited to sit fora scholarship exam that could open the doors to a promising academic career. However, he dreams of becoming a traditional puppeteer, a dying art form. In the middle of the exams, he suffers a crisis of confidence and decides to follow his artistic dreams rather than the more prosaic career option strongly advocated by his parents and other family members. Despite a strong storyline, the music does not have much emotional resonance.

Directed by Goh Boon Teck, December Rains was first staged in 1996 and again in 2010. The xinyao music was written by Liang Wern Fook and Jimmy Ye. The story is about rich girl Li Qing who falls in love with her schoolmate Ying Xiong, an idealistic left-wing revolutionary typical of 1950s Singapore. The girl’s parents object to their friendship and lock her at home so as to prevent the two from communicating with each other. Ying Xiong’s idealism drives him to go to China to support the Communist cause and he asks Li Qing to join him. However, she wants Ying Xiong to remain in Singapore and sends him a letter via a mutual friend, Ming Li, who has a crush on Li Qing. Ming Li fails to deliver the letter and Ying Xiong sails to China. Thirty years later, Li Qing’s daughter, Meng Yu, falls in love with Yang Guang, an actor from China, but Li Qing disapproves of this union. History is about to repeat itself until Ming Li intervenes and persuades Li Qing to give Yang Guang a chance. When Yang Guang’s adoptive parent’s fly in to Singapore, Li Qing takes the opportunity to meet them. Yang Guang’s adoptive father turns out to be Ying Xiong! Ming Li finally decides to reveal that he was the one who failed to deliver Li Qing’s letter to Ying Xiong, but just before he manages to confess, he dies from a heart attack. The xinyao music is pleasant and melodic, but too many ballads prevent the musical from reflecting the emotional highs and lows of the drama. The development of Li Qing and Ying Xiong’s love is perhaps too rushed and one does not feel for them.

In 2011, Goh Boon Teck, the director of Toy Factory Productions, adapted Royston Tan’s 2007 film 881 as a musical. Staged at the Esplanade, the musical tells the story of two friends, Min Min and Yan Yan, who dream of singing in the Seventh Month Ghost Festival stage (getai). They seek the help of an ex-getai singer, Ling, who helps them rehearse and gives them their stage name, ‘Papaya Sisters’ (which sounds like ‘881’ in Mandarin). Three deities (Fu, Lu and Shou) narrate the story, help the Papaya Sisters, and provide slapstick comic relief. Competing for the same getai stage are the irritating Durian Sisters from Romania. The Papaya Sisters’ prospects end abruptly when Min Min collapses from an undiagnosed brain tumour and eventually dies. 881 is a jukebox musical featuring old Hokkien songs that used to be very popular in their day.

Dance is the weakest element of Singapore musicals. In general, the choreography is unadventurous and the dancers are not well synchronised. The lack of good dancers may be due to the decline in popularity of jazz ballet, modern and abstract dance. Most young dancers in Singapore are learning hip-hop, which does not have the range of expression or subtlety of interpretation seen in jazz ballet, for example. As a result, many Singapore musicals have little or no dancing.

In an effort to forge a more systematic developmental process, an association called Musical Theatre Society (later renamed Musical Theatre Live!) Was set up in 2004. This organisation discovers new creative talent and helps find collaborators for writers and composers. It nurtures talent by inviting experienced playwrights, composers and directors to critique and mentor the creative teams. Readings of the embryonic musical are conducted in front of small groups, and when ready for public display a staged reading is performed in front of an invited audience that includes producers from established theatre companies who are invited to take up the work for commercial staging. To date, this organisation has incubated over 30 new musicals, including Georgette by Ng Yi-Sheng and Clement Yang, about the life of Singapore artist Georgette Chen. This musical was staged in Singapore and the Philippines in 2007. There have been several experimental short musicals, like 10 Days of Mourning by Carolyn Camoens, who is active in the Singapore Indian arts scene. This musical featured traditional Indian music composed by Nawaz Mirajkar in 2006. Another experimental musical from 2006 was The Swami, the Cow and the Spaceman by Musa Fazal, with music by Sean Wong.

One advantage Singapore has over the West End and Broadway is that the cost of a production remains relatively low. A reasonably good production can be mounted for around $750,000. This contrasts with the multiple millions of dollars that must often be spent in the West. Also, the theatres in Singapore are relatively new and are equipped with state-of-the-art acoustics and stage facilities. However, assembling the right team of producers, directors, choreographers, performers, musicians, lighting and sound designers and stage managers remains a perennial problem. It must be remembered that the Singapore musical started in 1988 virtually from scratch and over the past two decades production companies have gradually built up their expertise. This is a continuing evolution and remarkable progress has already been made.

The term ‘triple threat’ refers to performers capable of singing, dancing and acting. Local performers who possess this ‘triple threat’ are rare, so the same faces tend to crop up in many musicals. Since 2004, there has been only one school – LASALLE College of the Arts – that offers a degree course in musical theatre. Even though only a very small handful of Singaporeans manage to pass the audition to enter this school, the musical theatre course will probably play an important role in supplying well-trained performers in the long run.

Musical theatre in Singapore is fresh and energetic. It is influenced by both the West and the East, and in time, will find its own unique voice. But the future of the Singapore musical depends on the creation of many more new works, on audience development, on increased corporate and government support, and further liberalisation in the attitudes of the funding bodies.

Selected Musicals

Makanplace (1988) takes pride of place in being the first Singapore musical to be staged. The book on which the musical is based was written by R. Chandran. The librettist was Jasmin Samat Simon, who also composed the music with Saedah Samat. It was produced by Act 3, directed by R. Chandran and choreographed by Richard Tan. Set in a hawker centre, it revolves around the lives of those who work there, those who come and go, and how their lives intertwine. It highlights the value of friendship and of chasing dreams. The music is jaunty with pleasant melodies. Altogether the show contains 10 songs, including two reprises. Notable songs include ‘Makanplace’ and ‘Where Do We Go from Here?’ The musical was first staged at Victoria Theatre and a few years later restaged at The Drama Centre. A made-for-television version was aired by Singapore Broadcasting Corporation in the early 1990s.

Beauty World (1988) was first staged at the World Trade Centre Auditorium. The script was written by Michael Chiang, with music and lyrics by Dick Lee. It was produced by TheatreWorks, directed by Ong Keng Sen and choreographed by Najip Ali. Set in Singapore in 1965, the story follows Ivy Chan Poh Choo, an illegitimate child abandoned by her family in smalltown Batu Pahat, Johor. The only clue to her heritage is a broken jade pendant with the words ‘Beauty World’ inscribed on its back. She comes to Singapore in search of her father, meets up with her dotty pen friend, who informs her that Beauty World is a sleazy nightclub in Singapore. She meets Lulu the main cabaret dancer, Mummy the mother figure, Ah Hock a gangster and bartender, and eventually Boss Quek, the owner of the club. One of the patrons of the club, Towkay Tan, lures Ivy to a room upstairs and attempts to rape her. Luckily, she is rescued by Ah Hock, who is attracted to her. Eventually, Ivy learns who her parents are and there is a happy ending. The dialogue uses Singlish quite liberally, which raises laughs with the local audience. Dick Lee’s music is pleasant with a style out of the 1950s. The most memorable tunes are ‘Beauty World Cha Cha Cha’, ‘Single in Singapore’ and ‘Ivy’. The musical had a second run in 1992, and went on tour in the Japanese cities of Fukuoka, Hiroshima, Osaka and Tokyo in September 1992. In 1998, it was reproduced as a television musical production for the fourth President’s Star Charity.

Fried Rice Paradise was originally produced in 1991, but was completely rewritten by Dick Lee to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the People’s Association in 2010. Set in the 1970s, the story centres on Bee Lean, who is trying to save her father’s coffee shop from being bought over by Rickson Goh, the owner of a disco joint. She is also trying to save their entire row of shophouses from being repossessed. Bee Lean’s idea is to transform her father’s coffee shop and attract more customers by selling her mother’s famous fried rice recipe. The most memorable song is ‘Fried Rice Paradise’. Unfortunately, it takes almost half the musical just to set up the plot and the insertion of community songs is a bit forced.

Big Bang! (1995) was staged at the Kallang Theatre. The script was written by Stephen Yan, the lyrics by Desmond Moey, and the music by Kenneth Lyen and Desmond Moey. Additional music was written by Adrian Oh. It was directed by Bob Turoff. The story is based on the life of Cambridge cosmologist, Stephen Hawking, and covers the history of astronomy from the ancient Chinese, through Galileo, Isaac Newton, Albert Einstein and Fred Hoyle. Memorable songs include ‘Big Bang!’, ‘I like Your Mind’ and ‘Stars’. The music was also used during the opening of Fusionopolis in 2008, with Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong in attendance.

Sing to the Dawn (1996) was produced by the Singapore Repertory Theatre and staged at the Kallang Theatre. The script was written by Ho Minfong and Stephen Clark, with lyrics by Stephen Clark and music by Dick Lee. It was directed by Steven Dexter and choreographed by Gani Abdul Karim. Based on Ho Mingfong’s novel of the same name, Sing to the Dawn is the story of Dawan, a Thai peasant girl who wins a scholarship to study in the city, but has to overcome parental and societal objections to achieve her goal. Despite such a simple storyline, the book explores the deep emotional conflicts both within and outside the family. The music captures the ethnic character of Thailand and covers a wide range of moods. Three songs stand out: ‘My Child’, ‘The City’ and ‘It Just Flies’. The musical is unrelated to the 2008 animation with the same title and story.

Chang and Eng (1997) was written by Ming Wong with music and lyrics by Ken Low. It was directed by Ekachai Uekrongtham and choreographed by Mohd. Noor Saman. The story is based on the life of a pair of Siamese twins, Chang and Eng. They are taken from Thailand and brought to America to be part of a freak show. They meet a pair of American twins with whom they fall in love, marry and produce a total of 21 children. Ken Low wrote a varied score ranging from the comic ‘The Grand Midwife of the West’ to touching ballads like ‘From Now On’ and ‘Mai Phen Rai’. The show was a commercial success and toured China, Hong Kong and Thailand.

Temptations (2000) was produced by the Rainbow Theatre. The script was written by Kenneth Lyen, with lyrics by Desmond Moey and music composed by Kenneth Lyen, Desmond Moey and Iskandar Ismail. The show was directed by Jonathan Lim. The story is about food critic Shawn who takes his fellow reporter and date, Leila, to a high-class restaurant called ‘Temptations’. But because of their improper dress, the snobbish restaurant owner, Cat, treats them condescendingly. As a result, Shawn writes a poisonous article about the restaurant in his newspaper column. Cat subsequently turns up at Shawn’s newspaper office to protest, but Shawn refuses to retract his article. Not long after Cat and her restaurant’s cook go for drinks at a nearby café where they bump into Shawn and Leila again, and all four are forced to share a table. It slowly becomes apparent that behind the duelling words of Shawn and Cat is a subtext that they are actually enjoying each other’s company. The unlikely pair gradually fall in love and a series of events draw them closer. There is a subplot concerning a cross-dressing cook and Leila. Four other actors make up a Greek chorus and act as intermediaries to the audience. The highlights of the musical are the songs that drive the plot forwards, including ‘No Slippers, No Shorts’, ‘Getting Burnt’ and ‘Manya’s Story’.

Forbidden City (2002) was first commissioned to mark the opening of Esplanade – Theatres on the Bay. The script was written by Stephen Clark and Dick Lee, with lyrics by Stephen Clark and music by Dick Lee. The musical draws from Sterling Seagrave’s controversial biography of Empress Dowager Cixi. It narrates her struggle for survival behind the closed doors of the Forbidden City, maintaining her power in the face of calumny from her own subjects as well as the English press. The story is told from the point of view of American painter Kate Carl and an unscrupulous British journalist George Morrison. There is comic relief provided by the Record Keepers. The music is pleasant and enhances the drama. Forbidden City was restaged in 2003 and 2006.

Phua Chu Kang (2005) was staged at the Kallang Indoor Stadium. The script is unaccredited; the lyrics were written by Edmund Ooi, Catherine Casey, Vivienne Lin and Adeline Tan, and the music composed by Edmund Ooi and Peter Casey. The show was directed by Edmund Ooi and choreographed by Bill Calhoun. The story finds contractor Phua Chu Kang on the brink of turning 40. He drops copious hints to his relatives and workers, but they all pretend not to know while secretly planning a surprise birthday party. In the meantime, Phua Chu Kang’s arch nemesis, Frankie Foo, is angry that Chu Kang had stolen his childhood sweetheart Rosie and vows vengeance. He plants one of his relatives, a Chu Kang lookalike who claims to be Chu Kang’s brother Chu Kok. Chu Kang is hoodwinked by this imposter, who takes him to see a Feng Shui master. The latter informs Chu Kang that he will die on his 40th birthday. Depressed, Chu Kang signs away his house and all his belongings to his brother. Chu Kang’s family is angry and upset that everything has been given away to this fraudulent brother. Just as the villainous Frankie Foo is about to claim Phua Chu Kang’s home and evict the entire family, he has a heart attack. Phua Chu Kang resuscitates Frankie, who then tears up the contract, but secretly vows to destroy his savior in the future. The story is predictable and the set-up takes too long. The music is largely functional and some of the songs do not advance the plot or enhance characterisation.

Georgette (2007) was produced by Musical Theatre Ltd and staged at the Esplanade Recital Studio. The script and lyrics were written by Ng Yi-Sheng and the music by Clement Yang. The musical focuses on the life of Singapore artist Georgette Chen during her younger, formative years. The first half sets the tone by focusing on the relationship between Georgette and Eugene, an ethnic Chinese from Trinidad who is twice her age and eventually becomes the foreign minister of China. Georgette is fiercely independent while Eugene is reserved. Nevertheless, they marry against the wishes of Georgette’s wealthy parents. The story follows the pair as they travel from China to Paris to Trinidad and are ultimately caught by the sweep of history. They are imprisoned by the Japanese in Shanghai during the Second World War and they encounter communist forces. The music reflects the different countries and periods very well. It is one of the more innovative Singapore musicals. The show was also staged in the Philippines. Memorable songs include ‘Woman on the Wall’, ‘Don’t Cross Your Chopsticks’, ‘Raise the Flag’ and ‘A Bowl of Fruits’.

H is for Hantu (2009) was produced by Stages and originally staged at the Alliance Française Auditorium. The script and lyrics were written by Jonathan Lim and the music was composed by Bang Wensum. Puppets were designed, created and manipulated by Frankie Yeo. The show was directed by Jonathan Lim. Sazali is a schoolboy who can see hantu (Malay for ghosts). He is living in Singapore’s last remaining kampong, where a community of spirits lives nearby. When Angie Seah,a woman from the Housing Development Board, comes to evict the residents so that the kampong can be redeveloped, Sazali decides to fight the bureaucrats. However, it turns out that Angie is a victim herself, possessed by an unspeaking ghost who drives her to scramble through the jungle at night, searching for something. Sazali investigates and finds out that Angie used to live in that kampong as a child and her best friend, Swee Choo, a mute girl, died soon after her departure for city life. It comes to light that Angie is not a villain and actually fought hard to be put in charge of the kampong’s relocation so that she could ensure the residents were treated properly. Since one cannot defeat the government once it has made up its mind, it would be more pragmatic to get the best deal possible for the residents. When Angie offers them attractive new apartments, they are happy to move and ultimately keep their community together using a Facebook group. Angie eventually meets the ghost of Swee Choo face-to-face and presents her with the token of their friendship she has been searching for. The best thing about the show might be the puppets, which are spectacular. The music supports the mock spooky feel of the musical.

References

Atkey, Mel. A Million Miles from Broadway: Musical Theatre beyond New York and London. Toronto: Friendlysong Books, 2012.

Hales, Aaron. ‘The State on Stage: A Socio-Political Critique of Singaporean Musical Theatre.’ Ph.D. Dissertation, School of Music and School of Social and Cultural Studies, University of Western Australia, 2009.

Lee, Dick. The Adventures of the Mad Chinaman. Singapore: Marshall Cavendish, 2011.
Report of the Advisory Council on Culture and the Arts. Singapore, 1989.

Tan, Kenneth Paul. Renaissance Singapore: Economy, Culture, and Politics. Singapore: National University of Singapore Press, 2007.

Yeoh, Lizhen Geraldine. ‘The Singapore Musical: Perspectives, Paradigms, Practices.’ Honours Thesis, Department of Theatre Studies, National University of Singapore, 2011.

Singapura the musical

10 August 2015

Singapura: the musical
Reviewed by Kenneth Lyen
Scenes-from-Singapura-The-Musical 3

Maybe if I saw this show a few decades later, when memories of historical events have largely faded, where regional accents have merged into a nondescript form of global English, where style and pizazz are more important than character and plot development, I would rate Singapura a great show, aspiring to be Singapore’s Les Misérables. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed tonight’s performance immensely, but I will expound how I think it can be improved, below.

Singapura: the musical focuses on one family and how they are affected by the sweep of Singapore’s history from the 1955 Hock Lee bus riots, through Indonesian confrontation, the racial riots, and ending with Singapore expulsion from Malaysia in 1965.

The main strengths of this musical are the songs, the cast, the back projection and the moveable sets.

The majority of the cast are from the Philippines. The Filipino accent was largely subdued and I was not bothered by it. Juliene Mendoza played the role of the father, and his strong voice and acting abilities carried the role brilliantly. Maybelle Ti played his wife, mother to Lee May, who was played by Marian Santiago. Lee May’s British boyfriend, Flynn, was played by David Bianco. The highlight of the musical is the powerful love duet “Be With Me” between Lee May and Flynn. Raymund Concepcion played the Man in White, ostensibly Lee Kwan Yew. He is a commanding figure with a sonorous voice to match. Comic relief is provided by Noel Rayos playing the Indian, and Onyl Torres playing the Malay character.

Ed Gatchalian composed, arranged, and directed the music. For me, music is an essential component of a musical, and in this regard, the music can be highly commended. It is strident during the turbulent scenes, it is romantic during the courting scenes, sad when the mother dies, and triumphant at the finale. The songs are catchy and well arranged.

Driscoll Otto’s back projection demonstrates how photos and illustrations can greatly enhance the scenes and replace expensive sets. It is a definite wow factor.

David Permana conducted the orchestra and accompanied the singers faultlessly.

What could have been improved? The first half felt too long. The musical started off by placing too much emphasis on the history of Singapore rather than developing the individual characters. To some extent this was obviated in the second half. I did not like any of the university law lecturer’s scenes, and would have preferred to have all these scenes deleted. The over-emphasis on the role of the British after they had granted independence to Singapore overshadowed other historical elements. The lack of a satisfactory conclusion between Lee May and her British lover Flynn left me a bit confused. The father’s fears of the perils of Singapore are understandable, but his wish to emigrate to a utopian Malacca portrayed him as bit of a coward. To overcome this negative portrayal, I think his character arc needs more careful development: instead of running away from his problems, time needs to be taken to show how he confronts them. I would have liked to have seen the character playing Lee Kwan Yew to pay a visit to the kopitiam, take a drink, and have a brief conversation with the father. Finally, being a musical set in Singapore, I think more sprinkling of local languages and Singlish would enhance its authenticity.

So ultimately, we come back to the subject matter of the musical. If it is about Singapore, then it falls short. Hence the low score given below. Sorry.

However, I did enjoy the musical. And I would like to congratulate the creative team, the cast, the orchestra, and everyone involved in this musical for their magnificent effort!

2 June 2015

1.5 out of 5 stars

LKY the musical

10 August 2015

LKY: the musical

Reviewed by Kenneth Lyen

 LKY 7

This hagiographic biography of the first prime minister of Singapore is entertaining and well-performed. It also paints a panoramic history of Singapore from the 1940s until its independence in 1965. The sets are good, the use of back projections of historical photographs is effective, and the orchestration excellent.

However, as a musical, I left the Marina Bay Sands theatre with a sense of disappointment. This is not to say that it was bad. Indeed, there’s a lot to like about this musical.

The acting and singing are superb. Adrian Pang is a believable young LKY. He captures the tenderness of his love for his wife, his quick-thinking to escape from the Japanese, his charisma as leader of his political party to fight the British and later the communists. Sharon Au is the only female in the entire cast, but she pulls off her role as the wife of LKY, able to stand up to him as his equal. She is the weakest performer in this musical, but I did not mind it too much. Benjamin Chow is a talented actor-singer and there is a faint resemblance to the real Lim Chin Siong who he portrays. But his British accent mars him of believability as this left-wing extremist who is accused of having a secret agenda to take over political control of Singapore. Radhi Khalid acts the role of poker-playing Tunku Abdul Rahman, whose initial opposition to Singapore’s desire to merge with Malaya to form Malaysia makes him another antagonist. But having met and spoken to the late Tunku Abdul Rahman, I think that Radhi’s portrayal is really too off the mark. The rest of the supporting cast are good.

The lyrics are generally well-written. But overall, the songs are unmemorable. Dick Lee has written far better material in the past. The opening song of the second act is incongruous to the rest of the musical.

The three-tier sets are well-designed and used effectively. The direction and the technical aspects of the production are excellent.

The problem with the musical is that it tries to cover too much in the time allocated. It spans the period from Lee Kuan Yew’s schooldays when he came second in the final exams to Kwa Geok Choo, his future wife, to the separation of Singapore from Malaysia. I felt that Lee Kuan Yew is portrayed too superficially. There is little depiction of any inner struggles, and the love story between LKY and Geok Choo is painted too perfunctorily. The villain, Lim Chin Siong, is inadequately characterized, because we do not know what really drives him: is it ideology or ambition or both?

It is possible to write a historical musical where the ending is known beforehand, and yet maintain a degree of suspense throughout the musical. Sadly this is lacking in LKY the musical. Lee’s triumphs are rendered too predictable and the musical lacked emotional depth.

As a musical hoping to succeed in the West End or Broadway for an international audience, I doubt that, in its current form, it can realize this ambition.

But as a musical directed for a Singapore audience, it succeeds.

Congratulations!

24 July 2015

2/5 Stars

Nanyang the musical

10 August 2015

Nanyang: the musical

Reviewed by Kenneth Lyen

Nanyang 1

You should watch Nanyang the musical, loosely based on the lives of artists Liu Kang and Georgette Chen.

Watch it to learn how not to write a musical. Nearly everything that you should not do is done here.

Character Development

To write a good musical you need to develop the main characters. Nanyang the musical has three pairs: male art student Chen Kang who falls in love with female artist Miss Li Ting; art student Mr Ren Hao who falls in love with fellow student Miss Yue Ping; and male art instructor Zhang Wen who is married to Balinese dancer Nini. Unfortunately, the bookwriter seems unable to handle this large number of protagonists, and would have done better to have cut the number down. There is no antagonist, so there is little tension generated between these main characters.

Plot

The plot is confusing. Chen Kang has just enrolled in the Xinhua Art Academy in Shanghai during the second world war just before the Japanese occupation of China. There seems to be some demonstration outside the academy. He is immediately attracted to fellow artist, Miss Li Ting. When she accidentally drops her purse at the end of the lesson, Chen Kang finds it, and upon returning it to Li Ting, quickly becomes infatuated by her. He spends the rest of the musical trying to chase after her. Then quite abruptly all these protagonists suddenly decide to go to Paris which is under Nazi occupation. Art instructor Zhang Wen successfully auctions one of his paintings, which apparently is controversial. But as we never see the painting, we cannot gauge how controversial it really is. In Paris, Ren Hao and Yue Ping announce their plans to marry, and to have their honeymoon in Bali, where Zhang Wen and Chen Kang have already decided to travel. In the meantime, Li Ting announces that she is going to America. In Bali, we discover that Zhang Wen is already married to Balinese dancer Nini and they have a young son. Then Zhang Wen receives a letter from Li Ting announcing that she is gone to Singapore. So they all travel to Singapore to meet Li Ting. Unfortunately on arrival, the Japanese who have occupied Singapore learn that the painter of the controversial painting, Zhang Wen is in that group, and want to arrest him. Initially Chen Kang claims that he is Zhang Wen, but realizing that the Japanese intend to shoot the painter, Zhang Wen gives himself up. (Spoiler alert). He is shot dead.

It is not made clear why the artists went to Nazi-occupied Paris, why the auctioned painting was so controversial as to warrant execution, and why it fell to the Japanese in Singapore to carry out the execution. In short, the plot is a mess.

Show, Don’t Tell

There are large tracts where back story is narrated. For example, Zhang Wen spends a considerable amount of time relating his past history which ideally should have been acted out. The opening scene asserts that the visual arts are an important component of life, and can act as a catalyst for revolution. But we do not see any of the art pieces, so we are unconvinced by this claim.

Imbalance

The Bali segment seems irrelevant. Far too much time is spent dancing. As there is no dancing in the other scenes, the forced injection of dance here, which does not advance the plot, makes the entire scene somewhat extraneous.

Songs

A musical must justify its use of songs. It can develop character, set the mood, advance the plot, create conflict, and intensify love scenes. Unfortunately the songs seem to be inserted erratically. This is not to say that the songs are bad individually. In fact, music is one of the saving graces of the musical.

Verdict

Nanyang the musical sadly fails in many areas. The characters are poorly developed, the plot is confusing, there is little emotional pull, and the abrupt ending is most unsatisfying. It is one of the worst commercial musicals staged in Singapore. This is a pity as it is the opening show for the Singapore International Festival of Arts 2015.

Nanyang pales in comparison with Ng Yi-Sheng’s musical Georgette, which covers the same artists.

http://www.kenlyen.com/gpage62.html

1/5 stars
6 August 2015
Director and Writer: Alex Tok
Lyricist: Xiaohan
Composer: Eric Ng
Music Director: Goh Kheng Long
Choreographer: Andy Benjamin Cai
Set Designer: Izmir Ickbal
Costume Designer: Yvette Ng

——————————————–

Review of Nanyang the Musical by Mohamad Shaifulbahri on 1st Sept 2015:

It was most unfortunate that my Singapore International Festival of Arts (SIFA) 2015 experience started with Nanyang the Musical. The work felt like an incomplete one and the writing was not particularly strong. Sure, we can debate about what a festival commission should look but the work just felt like it was not ready for the festival stage. Some of the directorial decisions made were also questionable like the odd decision to have many moments of silence during transitions (making one wonder if this was really a musical) and the Bali parts but other elements of the production made the watching more bearable though I must say that the choice to play with the projections on luggage was inspiring. The musical had a good cast that delivered and the score was fantastic and this made the show a little bit more bearable.